The Supreme Court refused Alan Martin Moyne leave to appeal on 13 February 2025, so his defamation claim against a barrister, a firm of solicitors and others will not be heard further. Mr Moyne had applied to bring the case from the Court of Appeal.
His claim arose from a Circuit Court hearing in which the barrister, acting for Tanager DAC in a possession case over property owned by Mr Moyne and his wife, said a land registry document he had exhibited was an altered copy. He sued the barrister, the firm, its partners and Tanager directors for damages.
The High Court struck out the claim as bound to fail, finding the statement was made on an occasion of absolute privilege under the Defamation Act 2009. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on all eight grounds.
The Supreme Court panel of Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. said he could not raise for the first time a challenge to the constitutionality of that law. It said disagreeing with the lower courts was not a basis for a further appeal, and he had not met the constitutional threshold.