The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Millbourne Residents Association in its case against An Bord Pleanála over an apartment development near Ashbourne, County Meath. It granted the association leave on 11 February 2025 to appeal directly from the High Court. Dunne J., Woulfe J. and Hogan J. made the determination.
The association challenged the board's decision to grant planning permission. Rybo Partnership is a notice party. The board conceded that the Appropriate Assessment under the Habitats Directive was invalid. The High Court therefore quashed the permission by consent.
The dispute is about what happens next. Bolger J. ordered the matter to be sent back to the board, in a judgment of 24 January 2024. The association says it should go back to the planning authority instead, because Meath now has a new county development plan.
The board and Rybo Partnership oppose that. They say sending the case back to the board is lawful and appropriate. Bolger J. refused leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal on 9 October 2024, so the association applied to the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court said the application raises an important issue of principle about the power to remit under section 50A(9A) of the Planning and Development Act 2000. Remittal to the board is mandatory except in rare and exceptional cases where it would not be lawful.
The question is whether a change in the development plan makes remittal to the board unlawful. A further question is whether the board can decide a case under a different plan from the one the planning authority applied. The court said this could affect many other planning decisions.
What is still undecided is the outcome of the appeal. The court will hold a case management hearing in very early course to speed up the hearing and to clarify the grounds.