Alan Ward has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over the killing of his wife, Catherine Ward. Charleton J., Collins J. and Donnelly J. gave the determination on 17 January 2025. The court did not grant leave from the Court of Appeal judgment of 27 June 2024.
Ms Ward died on 1 March 2019. The couple had been married for 23 years. At his Central Criminal Court trial, Mr Ward accepted that he stabbed her. His main defence was diminished responsibility, linked to a mental disorder and an acquired brain injury.
His application to the Supreme Court was made on 19 December 2024, which was out of time.
He argued that the prosecution psychiatrist should not have given an opinion on the ultimate issue. The defence psychiatrist, he said, had done the same. The Director of Public Prosecutions said both experts gave their evidence in accordance with law.
The Supreme Court said an appeal was neither necessary nor in the interests of justice. It said both psychiatrists laid a foundation for their opinions, and neither said whether he was guilty. He had to prove a substantial diminution in responsibility not caused by intoxication, and did not succeed.
The constitutional threshold for an appeal was not reached.