The Supreme Court granted Niall Byrne leave to bring a direct appeal from the High Court in his challenge to the presidential nomination process, in a determination dated 19 December 2025. The appeal is limited to one point: whether a party leader's direction to local authority members on who to nominate can be examined by the courts.
Mr Byrne announced on 5 September 2025 that he would seek to run for President as an independent. He said the Tánaiste, as Fine Gael leader, then directed local councils to block or discourage independent nominations. The respondents are the Tánaiste, the Minister for Housing, the Attorney General and Ireland.
He issued a plenary summons on 8 October 2025 seeking declarations that the direction was unconstitutional and that the nomination process should be re-run. The High Court refused all reliefs on 21 October 2025 and struck out the proceedings as non-justiciable or bound to fail.
The High Court judge treated the direction as a political matter outside the courts' remit. The judge also held that Mr Byrne's argument that one part of the Constitution invalidated another was unstateable.
The Supreme Court said the appeal cannot affect the presidential election, which has taken place and is valid. A challenge to the result needed an election petition within seven days, and none was presented.
It found that an issue meeting the constitutional threshold had been raised about the nomination process. That concerns whether party leaders may direct local authority members to back a particular candidate rather than make an independent choice.
The court proposed two issues, subject to refinement at case management. The first is whether such a direction is justiciable. The second is whether, if it is, it was an impermissible interference with the nomination process under Article 12.
It also pointed Mr Byrne to the legal representation scheme run through the Incorporated Law Society of Ireland and the Bar Council. The panel was Justices Dunne, Charleton and Collins.