localnews.ie

Darren Foster refused Supreme Court appeal over costs of Mountjoy Article 40 case

By Gráinne Nolan

Historic decision · Decision date:

He was ordered to pay costs after withdrawing an Article 40 application over his detention and diet, and failed to overturn that order.

The Supreme Court refused Darren Foster leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on 26 November 2025. Dunne J, O'Malley J and Woulfe J made the determination in his case against the Governor of Mountjoy Prison.

Mr Foster began an inquiry under Article 40.4.2° of the Constitution into his detention. He later withdrew it. Section 169(4) of the Legal Services Regulatory Act 2015 says that a party who abandons proceedings normally pays the other side's reasonable costs.

On 21 November 2023, Hyland J. in the High Court ordered him to pay the costs. The basis of the application was the conditions of his detention, and in particular the diet he was given in prison given his medical history. She found no independent medical evidence linking his concerns to those conditions.

The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 20 February 2025. His solicitors said they had acted on genuine concerns for his health and had received no timely reply to their letters.

The Supreme Court accepted that the concern was genuine. It said the High Court applied well-established principles, and no clarification was needed. It found the application did not meet the constitutional threshold for a further appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal