The Supreme Court on 29 October 2025 refused Tom Ronan leave to appeal directly from the High Court in his case against the Garda Commissioner, Ireland and the Attorney General. O'Malley J, Murray J and Donnelly J made the determination.
Mr Ronan worked as a civilian driver for the Commissioner and was required to retire on turning 70 on 23 March 2023. He brought an age discrimination claim, and on 21 October 2024 a Workplace Relations Commission adjudication officer ruled in his favour and ordered that he be re-engaged. The Commissioner appealed to the Labour Court and refused to re-engage him.
Mr Ronan then began High Court proceedings and obtained an interim injunction requiring re-engagement. On 14 February 2025, Mulcahy J. discharged it. The judge held that the court had no jurisdiction to grant the injunction and that, in any event, he had not shown a strong case.
The Supreme Court said that a matter of general public importance will exceptionally arise at an interlocutory stage, and none did here. It called the High Court finding fact-specific and said the proper route was an appeal to the Court of Appeal.
It also noted that the Labour Court had since allowed the Commissioner's appeal on 15 August 2025, and the High Court hearing was listed for 18 and 19 November 2025.