localnews.ie

Peter Sweetman granted Supreme Court appeal over EPA poultry farm licence

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal concerns whether the Environmental Protection Agency must assess off-site landspreading of chicken manure when licensing a Limerick intensive broiler installation.

The Supreme Court on 28 October 2025 granted Peter Sweetman leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on an Industrial Emissions Licence for a poultry farm in County Limerick. Woulfe J, Hogan J and Collins J made the determination.

The Environmental Protection Agency granted the licence to Michael Noel O'Connor for an intensive broiler chicken installation. Mr Sweetman challenged it in the High Court and sought an order quashing the decision. Ireland and the Attorney General were also respondents.

His challenge centred on the off-site disposal of chicken manure. He argued that poultry litter and wash water are "emissions" and "waste". He said their use on lands outside the installation should have been assessed when the licence was granted.

On 23 January 2024, Bradley J. refused all the reliefs sought. He held that the Agency's powers under the Environmental Protection Agency Act 1992 applied to the activity licensed, which was the rearing of poultry within the installation boundary. The licence did not authorise or regulate the end-use of the litter or wash water on other lands.

The Court of Appeal, in a judgment of McGrath J. delivered on 28 February 2025, dismissed his appeal. The Agency opposed leave, saying the courts below applied well-established principles to the facts.

The Supreme Court found matters of general public importance. They concern any duty on the Agency to assess off-site landspreading of chicken manure, and whether poultry litter or wash water are "emissions" or "waste" under the 1992 Act. The court said these issues may arise in other cases and that clarity is in the public interest.

The grounds of appeal may be refined in case management.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal