The Supreme Court refused Brendan Kirwan leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 18 May 2023 on 28 October 2025. O'Malley J, Hogan J and Murray J made the decision.
Mr Kirwan's case is against Marguerite Connors, trading as M.J. O'Connor Solicitors, and others. The Court of Appeal had refused his application to reopen its earlier judgment of 26 October 2022. That judgment upheld the dismissal of his proceedings for inordinate and inexcusable delay.
This application was lodged on 10 July 2023. The Supreme Court had put it on hold while it heard his appeal on the main issue. It granted leave for that appeal on 16 March 2023.
The Supreme Court heard that appeal with five judges on 9 April 2024. It reopened the hearing before seven judges, with the Attorney General taking part, on 12 November 2024. On 30 May 2025, it unanimously agreed that the proceedings should be dismissed for delay.
Mr Kirwan's later application to set aside or vary those judgments was refused on 14 October 2025.
The court said the proceedings now stand dismissed by its final order. It said the matter is res judicata, meaning it has been finally decided, so leave to appeal was refused.