localnews.ie

John Sheridan Senior and others refused Supreme Court appeal over tax residency

By Tadhg O'Sullivan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The five applicants say they are not tax resident in Ireland and argued that the Criminal Assets Bureau should carry the burden of proving where they live.

The Supreme Court refused leave to appeal to John Sheridan Senior, John Sheridan Junior, Thomas Sheridan, Patrick Sheridan and Daniel Sheridan on 23 October 2025. Woulfe J, Hogan J and Collins J made the decision.

The Criminal Assets Bureau issued tax assessments against the five in March 2016, for income tax years going back as far as 2004. They appealed to the Tax Appeals Commission, saying they were not tax resident in Ireland.

The court heard that the first four say they are tarmacking contractors who work in other EU countries. Their tax consultant told the High Court that their caravans are the centre of their personal domesticity.

A Tax Appeal Commissioner ruled that the burden of proving residency lay with the applicants. They brought judicial review proceedings, arguing that the burden lay with Revenue. Owens J. rejected that in the High Court, and the Court of Appeal did the same on 9 May 2025.

The Supreme Court said the case turned on where the burden of proof lies. It found the Court of Appeal had fully analysed that point using well-established principles. It found no issue of general public importance and no need for leave in the interests of justice.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal