The Supreme Court refused Emmanuel Foley and Jeanette Afi Aboni leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 23 October 2025. They had taken the case against Dublin City Council.
The court said they should pursue the appeal they had already lodged in the Court of Appeal.
"this is a case where the appeal to the Court of Appeal should proceed," the determination said, in a ruling by O'Malley J, Collins J and Donnelly J.
The council had cut the couple's Housing Assistance Payment from 1 May 2023. It found that the rent included a figure for a car parking space, which the regulations did not allow HAP to cover. The couple remained liable for the full rent and fell into arrears.
On 24 July 2025, O'Regan J. dismissed their judicial review claim in the High Court. She held that they had not applied within the three-month limit and had not met the criteria for an extension of time.
The couple argued that the case would end up in the Supreme Court anyway. The court did not share that view. It said the issues were likely to be clarified and refined in the Court of Appeal.