The Supreme Court granted the Governor and Company of the Bank of Ireland leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 20 October 2025. Woulfe J, Hogan J and Collins J made the determination.
The bank is appealing against a High Court ruling of 2 April 2025 that refused its claim for surcharge interest from the late James Boyle. His estate is defended by Declan O'Boyle, as administrator.
Mr Boyle took out a loan from the bank in 2004 and defaulted on it. On 25 November 2017, the bank offered a new facility of €1,203,245 that included surcharge interest at 9%. It was due to be repaid by 15 May 2018.
The High Court gave the bank judgment for €1,154,639.94 on the debt. A separate claim for €204,501.23 in surcharge interest, accrued between August 2018 and May 2020, went to a plenary hearing.
Bolger J. found that the surcharge interest was a penalty as well as a means of recovering costs. She said it was not a genuine pre-estimate of the bank's loss. She also found it was unconscionable and extravagant, and refused the claim.
The bank argued that the law on penalties is uncertain and that the court should consider adopting the test from the UK Supreme Court's Cavendish decision. The estate did not object to leave being granted.
The Supreme Court found matters of general public importance in the enforceability of surcharge interest. It said the issues may arise in other cases and that clarity is in the public interest. It also found exceptional circumstances for a direct appeal.