The Supreme Court refused Atlantic Troy Limited leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision of 9 June 2025 in a dispute involving the Charleville Park Hotel. O'Donnell CJ, Charleton J and Hogan J gave the determination on 20 October 2025.
The respondents are members of the Traveller community who were homeless in September 2018. A Community Welfare Officer accompanied them to the hotel, which refused them a room under a policy requiring a credit card in the guest's own name. They claimed discrimination under the Equal Status Act 2000.
They succeeded before a Workplace Relations Commission adjudication officer, but the Circuit Court set that decision aside on appeal. The High Court later quashed the Circuit Court decision because the judge had intervened excessively in the hearing, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. The company did not dispute that finding.
The company argued that judicial review should have been refused because the respondents had not exhausted a statutory appeal. The Supreme Court said the lower courts applied settled principles. It held that the respondents were entitled to a remedy for the admitted unfairness, so no point of general public importance arose.
The ruling also governs two companion applications.