localnews.ie

Michael Lynn granted Supreme Court appeal over theft sentence

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The former solicitor was extradited from Brazil after 1,645 days in prison there, and the court will examine what credit he should get for that time.

The Supreme Court granted Michael Lynn leave to appeal his sentence for theft on 16 October 2025. Woulfe J, Hogan J and Collins J made the determination.

Mr Lynn, a former solicitor, was convicted by a jury on ten counts of theft. The thefts totalled €18,144,385 and involved six victims over approximately six months.

He was arrested in Brazil in August 2013. He contested extradition up to the Supreme Court of Brazil. He was extradited on 1 March 2018. By then he had spent 1,645 days in Cotel Prison in Recife. He then spent 105 days on remand in Ireland.

He was sentenced on 19 February 2024. The Circuit Court judge set a headline sentence of 16 years. That was cut to 13 years for mitigation, including that he had no prior record. A further 7½ years was deducted for the time in Brazil. The judge imposed 5½ years on each count, to run concurrently.

The Court of Appeal ruled on 13 May 2025. It found the judge had erred in dealing with the 105 days on remand in Ireland. It resentenced him to 5¾ years on each count, to run concurrently. It rejected his claim to remission for time served in Brazil.

The Supreme Court found the appeal raises issues of general public importance. These include what credit is due for time spent in custody abroad awaiting extradition. They also include whether harsh prison conditions abroad can earn enhanced credit. The court said these issues have never been considered by it.

It also noted that it could find the Court of Appeal's sentence too severe or too lenient.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal