The Supreme Court refused David Okojie leave to appeal directly from the High Court on 17 October 2025, in his case against the Minister for Justice. O'Donnell CJ, Charleton J and Hogan J made the decision.
Mr Okojie wanted to appeal a High Court order, made by Patrick McGrath J. on 3 June 2025, for his surrender to Italy. The order followed a European Arrest Warrant issued in Turin on 9 December 2024.
The warrant sought his surrender to serve the balance of a sentence imposed in 2006. The sentence was upheld and varied on appeal in 2022. His trial was held in his absence.
The Italian authority had certified that he would be told of his right to a retrial or appeal after surrender. Mr Okojie gave the High Court a letter from his Italian lawyer saying no further remedy was available in Italy.
The High Court asked the Italian authority whether the letter changed its assurances. It replied on 4 April 2025 that they remained unchanged and fully valid.
The Supreme Court found no point of law of general importance. It said the judge was entitled to accept the Italian authority's assurances, and no evidence had been put forward that such assurances had not been honoured in any other case.