localnews.ie

Una McClean granted Supreme Court appeal in Collector General tax case

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will test whether a solicitors' success-based fee arrangement used by the Collector General to recover unpaid tax is unlawful as champerty.

The Supreme Court granted Una McClean leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision on 19 September 2025, in a tax recovery case brought by the Collector General. Dunne J, O'Malley J and Hogan J made the determination.

The Collector General, named in the case as Joseph Howley, claims €599,541 including interest in unpaid taxes from Ms McClean. A Tax Appeals Commissioner affirmed that sum. Ms McClean does not accept the amount.

The High Court gave judgment for the full sum on 16 January 2024. Ms McClean had argued that the Collector General's fee deal with his solicitors was champertous. The Court of Appeal dismissed her appeal on 28 March 2025.

The contract gave the solicitors a fee of €270 plus VAT plus outlay. It also gave them 7% of the tax and interest charged as commission where collection was achieved on enforcement of a judgment.

The Supreme Court said the case raises important issues where the law on champerty is somewhat unclear. It pointed to the legality of a conditional uplift fee that depends on success and on the amount of tax and interest recovered. It noted that such arrangements have been common in Irish litigation for a long time.

Ms McClean also argued that the Court of Appeal had created uncertainty about the extent of a solicitor's security under the Legal Practitioners (Ireland) Act 1876. She asked for a priority hearing.

Leave was granted on the champerty issues only. The grounds may be refined in case management. An identical application, Howley v Howard, was also decided on the day.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal