The Supreme Court on 30 July 2025 granted leave to appeal to L.A. in her case against the Chief Appeals Officer, the Social Welfare Appeals Officer and the Minister for Social Protection. O'Malley J, Collins J and Donnelly J made the determination.
L.A. applied to the Department of Social Protection for disability allowance on 6 April 2022. A Deciding Officer refused it on 14 June 2022. An Appeals Officer disallowed her appeal on 22 September 2022 and, after a review, upheld that decision on 12 December 2022.
She then took judicial review proceedings. On 28 March 2024, Owens J. in the High Court found no obligation to seek a revision from the Chief Appeals Officer under section 318 of the Social Welfare Consolidation Act 2005 first. He quashed the December decision and sent the matter back for reconsideration.
On 5 March 2025, the Court of Appeal allowed the respondents' appeal and dismissed the proceedings. It held that the section 318 procedure was an adequate alternative remedy and that judicial review was therefore unavailable. On 14 May 2025 it made no order for costs.
L.A. applied for leave on 24 June 2025. The respondents opposed, saying the case applied well-established principles.
The Supreme Court found a matter of general public importance. It framed the question as what effect the section 318 route and the statutory appeal to the High Court under section 327 have on the right to seek judicial review of an Appeals Officer's decision. It said clarity was needed because social welfare entitlements can affect every resident.
The appeal will be case managed with A.B. v The Chief International Protection Officer, with initial case management in September. The two appeals may be heard together or one after the other.