The Supreme Court refused consultant surgeon Pawan Rajpal leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his dispute with the Health Service Executive. Dunne J, Woulfe J and Murray J gave the determination on 30 July 2025.
The HSE's chief executive placed Mr Rajpal on administrative leave on 3 January 2024, pending an investigation into the care of two patients. In the High Court, Nolan J granted an interlocutory injunction stopping the leave and restoring him to work, save for any work at Cavan General Hospital. This was an interim order made before a full trial.
On 28 February 2025, the Court of Appeal set aside that injunction. It held that he had not shown a strong case of breach of contract or fair procedures. It also found that the High Court had given too little weight to the interests of patients. It further found a serious lack of candour in his failure to disclose a criminal charge and his bail conditions. His application said he has since been acquitted.
The Supreme Court found no matter of general public importance, noting that interlocutory appeals rarely meet that test. It said a further appeal is not a vehicle for correcting error, and it found nothing to warrant an appeal in the interests of justice.