The Supreme Court has refused Arnaud Gaultier leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was delivered on 29 July 2024 by Justices O'Malley, Hogan and Murray. Mr Gaultier and Sup Pliable Limited are the plaintiffs in proceedings against Mark Reilly, Aine McGuigan and Louise Swords.
The only issue was a written judgment of Justice Cregan, delivered in January 2024, which refused to recuse himself as trial judge. Mr Gaultier asked the Supreme Court to hear an appeal bypassing the Court of Appeal, known as a leapfrog appeal. He also asked for an oral hearing, which the court did not consider necessary.
His case for a direct appeal was that two recent Court of Appeal judgments on recusal dealt only with objective bias. He said they did not consider European Court of Human Rights case law on subjective bias.
The Supreme Court said there was no reason for those judgments to address subjective bias. It noted that each one concerned a claim of objective bias only. It held that if Mr Gaultier alleges subjective bias and may argue it on appeal, he can take that appeal to the Court of Appeal in the normal way. The application did not meet the constitutional criteria for a direct appeal.