The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Patrick Dillon against Irish Life Assurance Public Limited Company. The court granted leave on 22 July 2024. Justices Dunne, Murray and Collins made the determination. The appeal goes directly from the High Court, because no other appeal route was open to him.
Mr Dillon held a life assurance policy with Irish Life. He alleged that letters containing his personal data were wrongly sent to an unauthorised third party over an extended period. He sued in the Dublin Circuit Court in June 2021 and sought a declaration of breach of the Data Protection Acts and the GDPR, and damages for distress, upset and anxiety.
Irish Life asked the court to strike the case out. It argued that the claim was for personal injuries, so it needed an authorisation from the Personal Injuries Assessment Board before it could proceed. Mr Dillon had none. The Circuit Court agreed with Irish Life and struck out the action.
The High Court judge, Justice O'Donnell, upheld that decision on 11 April 2024, "with some reluctance". He held that Mr Dillon's claim was a civil action for personal injuries. He saw no conflict with EU law in requiring the authorisation.
Mr Dillon says the decision will affect hundreds of other proceedings. He also asks the Supreme Court to revisit its earlier ruling in Murray v Budds.
The Supreme Court said it has never considered how non-material damage under the GDPR fits with the Personal Injuries Assessment Board rules. It called this an important and novel issue of general public importance. It also said there is a question over whether the authorisation requirement is compatible with Article 82 of the GDPR.
The case management judge may refine the grounds of appeal.