localnews.ie

Avril O'Halloran refused Supreme Court appeal against Mars Capital Finance Ireland over brackets in case title

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

She argued that a typing error in the lender's name made the High Court possession proceedings defective, and the Supreme Court did not agree.

The Supreme Court has refused Avril O'Halloran leave to appeal a High Court order in a possession case brought by Mars Capital Finance Ireland Designated Activity Company. The determination was delivered on 22 July 2024 by Justices Dunne, Murray and Collins. The dispute turned on brackets around the word "Ireland" in the lender's name.

The High Court, in a decision by Justice Stack on 20 March 2024, ordered Ms O'Halloran and a second defendant to deliver up the property and stay away from it. The order followed a Waterford County Registrar's Order for Possession dated 2 July 2018. The court also corrected the title of the proceedings.

Ms O'Halloran argued that the lender and its solicitors had no registered legal personality when the proceedings began. She said the error made the whole case defective and that she was unable to take steps in it.

The Supreme Court called the error a clear typographical error and said the correction was routine. It said the error could not in any conceivable way prejudice her. She was on notice of the High Court applications and was given the chance to file an affidavit, but chose not to.

The court found no point of general importance and no interests-of-justice ground for an appeal. It also found no exceptional circumstances to justify a direct appeal from the High Court.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal