The Supreme Court has refused David Fox leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in his case against the Data Protection Commissioner. The determination was delivered on 19 July 2024 by Chief Justice O'Donnell with Justices O'Malley and Murray. Mr Fox had already appealed in three courts.
Mr Fox worked as an attendant at the National Gallery of Ireland from 1991 to 2011. The Gallery ended his contract after allegations that he sent emails containing security-sensitive information. He had made a data access request and then complained to the Commissioner.
On 14 November 2019, the Commissioner upheld four of his seven complaints and rejected three. Those were about covert CCTV, access to his personal information and monitoring of his work email.
He appealed the rejected complaints. The Circuit Court ruled against him on 25 April 2022, and the High Court did so on 25 September 2023. The Court of Appeal agreed on 25 April 2024 that he had identified no point of law.
Mr Fox argued that the Gallery used inappropriate monitoring and held covert files. He also alleged apparent bias by the Circuit Court judge. The Commissioner opposed leave.
The Supreme Court held that his first three grounds raised no matter of general public importance. It said three levels of appeal had given comprehensive decisions. It found nothing to support the bias claim.