localnews.ie

Brian Murray granted Supreme Court appeal in Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank case over 2007 loan

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will examine whether a lender can claim unjust enrichment against a borrower who says he never signed the loan documents.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Brian Murray against Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank U.C. over a loan advanced in 2007. The court granted him leave on 16 July 2024. Justices O'Malley, Murray and Collins made the determination.

The dispute began with an earlier loan in 2003, secured by a charge over the Murrays' family home in Killybegs. In May 2007, the Bank advanced a second loan of €200,000, which redeemed the first. Mr Murray says he never signed the documents for either loan.

Repayments were made until June 2012. In April 2013, the Bank demanded payment and issued proceedings against Mr Murray and his wife, Attracta Murray, for €194,433.53 and interest.

In the High Court, Justice Baker was not satisfied that Mr Murray had signed the loan documents. She held the charge over the home void under the Family Home Protection Act 1976. She still found the Bank entitled to recover the principal from him, without interest, on the principle of unjust enrichment, because both defendants had the benefit of the money.

Mr Murray appealed to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed his appeal on 19 January 2024. It held that the Consumer Credit Act 1995 did not apply, because he had no agreement with the Bank. His wife was not allowed to pursue an appeal.

The Supreme Court said the case raises important points that it has not previously addressed. These include whether the Bank can claim unjust enrichment against Mr Murray when the 1995 Act protects borrowers. They also include the so-called leapfrogging point, because the Bank had obtained judgment against Mrs Murray.

The Bank also wants to argue that the 2007 loan was a housing loan under the Act. The court said that can be dealt with in case management, and the Bank is not excluded from relying on it.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal