localnews.ie

Patrick Kelly refused Supreme Court appeal against University College Dublin over judge bias claim

By Aoife Loughran

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Kelly was already granted leave on one bias issue in February 2024, and this second application raised more links between the judge and UCD.

The Supreme Court refused Patrick Kelly leave to appeal in his case against University College Dublin on 12 July 2024.

Mr Kelly's case began as a gender discrimination claim raised some 22 years ago. This application arose from a dispute about discovery of documents in the High Court.

He argued that the High Court judge was objectively biased. On 22 February 2024, the Supreme Court had already granted him leave on one issue. That issue was whether a judge's close relative working as a solicitor in a party's law firm met the test for objective bias.

Mr Kelly then sought to add links between the judge, his family and UCD. These included the judge's grandfather, father, aunts, wife and children. The case management judge refused to allow this.

The Supreme Court said it had already rejected the idea that a judge's ties to a university show bias. It said the new matters were too remote from the question of bias.

The panel was Justices Charleton, O'Malley and Collins. Mr Kelly's application was out of time, but the decision rested only on remoteness.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal