The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Iconic Newspapers Limited, publisher of the Limerick Leader, in a defamation case brought by William Bird. The court granted leave on 9 July 2024. Justices O'Malley, Woulfe and Collins made the determination.
The case concerns an article in the Limerick Leader dated 11 June 2016. It said Mr Bird had reached three settlements with the Revenue Commissioners over under-declared tax. The Revenue's quarterly Tax Defaulters' List, published in Iris Oifigiúil, named three companies called William Bird (Rollercoaster) Limited, William Bird (Sales) Limited and William Bird Tramore Limited. The list did not include Mr Bird, and he had no involvement in those companies. The journalist accepted at the hearing that his name was published by mistake.
The newspaper relied on qualified privilege under the Defamation Act 2009. Justice Owens ruled that the defence could not go to the jury. The jury found for Mr Bird and awarded him general damages of €75,000. The High Court refused a special certificate for costs on the High Court scale. The Court of Appeal dismissed the newspaper's appeal on 20 March 2024. It allowed Mr Bird's cross-appeal on costs, so he is entitled to High Court scale costs.
The Supreme Court said it has not yet considered whether the qualified privilege defence in section 18 can apply to statements published to the world at large. It also has not considered how section 18 relates to the defence in section 26. It said the case balances the right to a good name against freedom of expression. It also granted leave on the costs issue, to avoid a separate appeal on costs to the Court of Appeal.
Mr Bird asked for priority because of his advanced age and the time since 2016. The court agreed. A case management conference will be held in early September, on a date to be notified. The newspaper must file a notice of intention to proceed within two days. Its submissions are due within two weeks of that notice. Mr Bird then has three weeks.