The Supreme Court has granted John Kelly leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in a loan dispute with Cave Projects Limited. The determination was delivered on 25 January 2024. Mr Kelly is the second-named defendant in the case.
The High Court entered judgment for Cave Projects against Mr Kelly in the sum of €11,407,826.09. On 3 October 2023 the Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal in an ex tempore judgment.
The loan was advanced by Bank of Ireland to a partnership of five defendants. It culminated in a loan offer in excess of €12 million in 2007, for land development in Limerick, Clare and Galway. The debt was later acquired by NAMA, and then sold to Cave Projects, a company nominated by Pat McDonagh.
The High Court plenary hearing began on 29 November 2022 and ran for six days. One co-defendant settled on the fifth day, which left Mr Kelly as the only defendant in the case.
Mr Kelly represented himself in the Court of Appeal. He handed in a Central Bank press release of 21 September 2023, warning the public of its belief that Cave Projects was providing credit servicing without authorisation. He argued that this made the holding and enforcement of the loans an offence. The Court of Appeal said the issue had not been raised in the defence, argued in the High Court or supported by evidence.
His application to the Supreme Court was lodged on 27 November 2023. He had believed he had 28 days, when the period was 21 days, so he was out of time by two days. The court granted an extension of seven days.
Cave Projects opposed the application. It said the Central Bank matter was of regulatory significance and did not affect its entitlement to seek judgment.
O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. were not satisfied that the case raised an issue of general public importance. They granted leave in the interests of justice on one question only: how a court should address a credible assertion that recovering a loan is unauthorised and may be an offence.
The court said Mr Kelly can apply to the Registrar within 14 days for a solicitor and counsel to be assigned to argue the appeal.