localnews.ie

Jackson Way Properties refused Supreme Court appeal over 1947 restrictive covenant on South Dublin land

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had ruled that a covenant not to build, created in 1947, still binds land now crossed by the M50.

The Supreme Court has refused Jackson Way Properties Limited leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in its dispute with Thomas Kevin Smith and Mairead Smith. The determination was delivered on 1 July 2024. Dun Laoghaire Rathdown County Council was a notice party.

The case is about a covenant created in 1947 not to build on land in South Dublin. Jackson Way owns the land the covenant burdens. The Smiths own Priorsland and part of a neighbouring folio.

The M50 motorway now crosses the land. Arbitration awarded Jackson Way over 12 million euro for part of it, which the Council had compulsorily acquired. The Smiths later claimed compensation of nearly 6 million euro for their interest in the covenant.

The High Court held that the covenant's benefit was not annexed to the Smiths' land. The Court of Appeal reversed that on 21 July 2023. It declared the covenant in full force and effect for the benefit of the Smiths' land.

Jackson Way said the case raised new questions about implied annexation of covenants. The Smiths said the decision had very limited application.

The Supreme Court agreed that the facts were specific to this dispute between neighbours. It said the Court of Appeal had applied settled law. It found that neither general public importance nor the interests of justice was engaged.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal