localnews.ie

Michael Collins refused Supreme Court appeal over dangerous driving causing death conviction and self-representation

By Fionn Kelly

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Collins represented himself at his Trim Circuit Court trial after dismissing his legal team, and argued that he should not have been allowed to do so.

The Supreme Court has refused Michael Collins leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision upholding his convictions for dangerous driving causing death and other road traffic offences. The determination was delivered on 25 June 2024 by Justices Dunne, Hogan and Donnelly.

Mr Collins was convicted at Trim Circuit Court in March 2019. The counts included dangerous driving causing death, two counts of endangerment, drug driving and twelve counts of dangerous driving. The longest prison sentence was 10 years, with the final year suspended.

The convictions arose from events on 27 May 2016, when he drove through a Garda checkpoint and the wrong way round a roundabout near Drogheda. A crash followed, in which a back-seat passenger in another vehicle was killed.

Shortly before the third trial, Mr Collins dismissed his solicitors and counsel and defended himself. The Court of Appeal considered whether he had freely waived his right to legal assistance and delivered its judgment on 25 July 2023.

He argued that he was incapable of representing himself and asked the Supreme Court for further guidance on the right to waive counsel. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed leave.

The Supreme Court said a competent accused has a constitutional right to waive counsel, even where the decision is ill-advised. The medical evidence was that he was fit to plead, and his lawyers pointed to no specific unfairness in the trial. It held that he had not met the constitutional criteria.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal