The Supreme Court has refused Richard Whelan leave to appeal a High Court order that gave Mars Capital Ireland Designated Activity Company possession of a property. The determination was delivered on 12 June 2024 by Justices Dunne, Hogan and Donnelly. Cora Whelan, the second defendant, did not apply.
A loan was advanced to the Whelans, who offered property as security. They defaulted on the mortgage repayments. Mars Capital then sought possession through a Civil Bill in the Circuit Court.
The Circuit Court granted possession and directed a sale on 5 March 2020. Any remaining equity was to go to Cora Whelan after costs. The High Court, on 24 April 2023, refused the defendants' appeal and affirmed that order.
Mr Whelan asked the Supreme Court to set both orders aside. He claimed Mars Capital was wrongly registered with the Property Registration Authority as owner of the charge. He made general allegations of fraud.
The Supreme Court said the register is conclusive evidence of title under section 31 of the Registration of Title Act 1964, and broad assertions of wrongdoing do not displace it. A claim of wrongful registration should go to the Property Registration Authority, now Tailte Éireann.
The court also said an appeal from the High Court needs exceptional circumstances, and he put none forward. He did not meet the constitutional threshold, so leave was refused.