The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Patrick Sparling against an order for his surrender to the United Kingdom. The court granted him leave on 5 June 2024. Justices Dunne, Hogan and Donnelly made the determination.
The High Court had ordered his surrender on a Trade and Co-operation Arrest Warrant dated 6 December 2022. The warrant covers 39 fraud-type offences.
It also records that he was sentenced to six months in prison for contempt of court. That arose from restraint orders made against him under the UK Proceeds of Crime Act 2002. The warrant states that breaching a restraint order is not a criminal offence.
Mr Sparling objected under the rule of specialty. He argued that he would face a sentence he was not surrendered for. He said "offence" in the 2003 Act should carry a broad EU law meaning.
The High Court rejected that argument in a judgment delivered on 8 April 2024. Justice Greally held that the sentence was for civil contempt. She found it fell outside the rule. The High Court refused leave to go to the Court of Appeal.
The Supreme Court said the case raises an issue of general public importance. The question is whether "offence" has an autonomous EU meaning that could cover deprivations of liberty imposed in civil proceedings.
It also found exceptional circumstances, so the appeal can go straight from the High Court. There is no other appeal route, and the case concerns liberty.
The court agreed to a priority hearing because Mr Sparling is in custody. He must file submissions by 14 June 2024. The Minister for Justice and Equality then has until 24 June 2024. An early date for case management will be set.