localnews.ie

Brian Shaughnessy refused Supreme Court appeal over rape conviction and complaint about his solicitor

By Donal Gilhooly

Historic decision · Decision date:

The case had already been before the Supreme Court once, which sent it back so the Court of Appeal could hear oral evidence.

The Supreme Court has refused Brian Shaughnessy leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's rejection of his challenge to his rape conviction. The determination was delivered on 13 May 2024 by Justices Charleton, Woulfe and Collins.

The case had been before the Supreme Court before. In a 2021 judgment it set out how claims of incompetent legal representation should be handled. It sent the case back to the Court of Appeal to hear oral evidence on the clash between Mr Shaughnessy's account and that of his former solicitor.

Mr Shaughnessy said his solicitor did not follow his instructions, and that his defence on the timing of the alleged offence was never properly put. The Court of Appeal heard the evidence and dismissed his appeal on 31 October 2023. It was not persuaded that the trial was unfair or that the conviction was unsafe.

He argued that a conviction should not stand where there is no other independent evidence untainted by the alleged incompetence. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the application.

The Supreme Court said the Court of Appeal had analysed the facts thoroughly and applied the test from its 2021 judgment. It said his application turned on the facts of his own case.

It held that neither general public importance nor the interests of justice was met.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal