The Supreme Court has refused Michael Murray leave to appeal against a prison punishment of 40 days' loss of privileges. The determination was delivered on 13 May 2024 by Justices Charleton, Woulfe and Collins.
The sanction came from the Governor of Midlands Prison after Mr Murray threw a bible at the sentencing judge in the Circuit Criminal Court on 29 July 2021. The judge decided not to impose any sanction for contempt. Mr Murray was serving a 19-year sentence for sexual offences at the time.
He challenged the discipline by judicial review. His argument was that a prisoner in court is in the "custody of the court", so he was not a prisoner under the Prisons Act 2007 and the Prison Rules 2007. Misconduct there, he said, could only be dealt with as contempt.
The High Court rejected that argument and the Court of Appeal agreed on 22 February 2024. Both held that the governor acted within his powers.
His application to the Supreme Court was late, and time was extended.
The Supreme Court said that being liable for contempt did not stop the prison rules applying to him. It said he was at all times in the governor's custody under the 19-year sentence.
Leave to appeal was refused.