The Supreme Court has refused Marlies Walsh leave to appeal her conviction for harassment. The determination was delivered on 7 May 2024. Her sentence includes an order not to contact Dr Atif Awan for 20 years.
The case arose after Ms Walsh's son was a transplant patient at Temple Street Hospital, where Dr Awan was in charge of his care. The determination records that she kept contacting Dr Awan and another consultant by phone, in person and by letter after her son was moved to a separate hospital. She also confronted Dr Awan outside work.
She was charged in April 2020 and pleaded guilty in the Dublin Circuit Criminal Court on 6 October 2022 to one count of harassment. On 24 November 2022 she received two years in prison, suspended on conditions for two years.
The Circuit Court also barred her from communicating with Dr Awan by any means for 20 years.
The Court of Appeal refused her appeal in November 2023. It treated the appeal as an attempt to set aside her guilty plea and found no reason to doubt the safety of the conviction.
Her application to the Supreme Court was late, and the court extended time. It held that the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles on setting aside a guilty plea, so no issue of general public importance arose. It also found that she had had a full hearing and gave no reason why the decision was wrong.