The Supreme Court has refused Philip Gaffney leave to appeal a Court of Appeal decision in his case against Alan Gaffney and Nicole Gaffney. The determination was delivered on 30 April 2024 by Justices Charleton, Woulfe and Collins.
Mr Gaffney had sued the two respondents in proceedings begun in 2017. The High Court, in a decision by Justice Barr, dismissed his action and found that the money at issue was a short-term loan rather than an investment in his business.
The High Court made no order as to costs. The Court of Appeal, in a judgment by Justice Binchy with Justices Whelan and Allen agreeing, set that order aside. It gave the respondents their costs of the 2017 proceedings, because they had been entirely successful in them.
Mr Gaffney asked the Supreme Court to hear a further appeal. The Supreme Court held that he had raised no issue of general public importance, because the Court of Appeal had applied well-established principles on costs to the facts of this case.
It also found that the interests of justice did not call for a further appeal. There had been a full hearing in the High Court on costs and an appeal to the Court of Appeal, and he had given no reason to argue that the decision was wrong.