localnews.ie

Philip Gaffney refused Supreme Court appeal in family loan dispute with his brothers

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal for want of prosecution after he did not appear on the day of the hearing.

The Supreme Court has refused Philip Gaffney leave to appeal. The determination was delivered on 30 April 2024. The case involves his brothers, Alan and Derek Gaffney.

The brothers said they lent money to Philip Gaffney and his wife Teresa in October 2015. The loan was to fund a contract with the American shopping channel QVC. That contract was worth approximately US$1.3M.

The brothers said the loan carried 15% interest. They said it was to be repaid when QVC paid. QVC cancelled the order in February 2016.

Philip Gaffney accepted that he received the money. He said it was an investment in his business, not a loan.

Barr J. found in the High Court that it was a short-term loan. He found Philip Gaffney was the sole borrower. He gave judgment for US$272,043.70 to Alan Gaffney and US$100,000 to Derek Gaffney.

Mr Gaffney appealed. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal for want of prosecution when he did not appear on the hearing date. It found he had been notified of the date many times.

He told the Supreme Court that he had been certified unwell and was denied a hearing. Charleton, Woulfe and Collins JJ refused leave. They found no matter of general public importance. He had a full hearing in the High Court, and the Court of Appeal was entitled to dismiss his appeal.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal