localnews.ie

Sangeeta Rana scheme case: Minister for Justice granted Supreme Court appeal

By Cathal Brosnan

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had quashed a refusal of permission under the Special Student Scheme, ruling by majority that a full assessment of the applicant's character was required.

The Supreme Court has granted the Minister for Justice leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in favour of Sangeeta Rana. The determination was delivered on 24 January 2024 and allows the Minister's appeal to proceed to a full hearing.

Ms Rana brought judicial review proceedings after the Minister refused her permission to reside in the State under the Special Student Scheme. The scheme was open to non-EEA nationals who held a student permission between 1 January 2005 and 31 December 2010, and it required applicants to be of "good conduct and character".

Ms Rana came to Ireland on a student permission in 2009. She was later given residence permission as the spouse of an EU national, but the Minister revoked it in May 2018 after forming the opinion that she had entered a marriage of convenience. She did not challenge that decision, and her Special Student Scheme application was refused on the basis of the earlier findings.

The High Court, in a judgment by Phelan J., dismissed her claim. It found no evidence of a fixed policy and held that the character references and work history were not enough to counter the revocation finding.

The Court of Appeal reversed that outcome by majority, with Faherty J. and Haughton J. in the majority and Costello J. dissenting. It held that a comprehensive assessment of character was required, and was not satisfied that the review decision-maker had carried one out.

Ms Rana opposed leave. She said she now has permission to reside, following a scheme for the regularisation of undocumented migrants in December 2022, and should not have to engage in litigation from which she can derive no benefit.

O'Malley J., Baker J. and Hogan J. granted leave. They said the issues, which also arise in the case of Lehrasib Ali, are matters of general public importance, including the obligation of a decision-maker to engage with an applicant's submissions. The appeal must also address the status of the unchallenged revocation decision in a later assessment of good character.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal