The Supreme Court has granted Declan Corcoran leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his case against the Director of Public Prosecutions. The determination was delivered on 30 April 2024.
Mr Corcoran is accused of identifying, on social media, two juveniles who were convicted of murder in June 2019, and of adding inflammatory comment. Section 252 of the Children Act restricted identification of the two. The offence under section 51 of that Act is triable either way, and summary disposal needs the consent of the DPP. On summary disposal it carries a fine and up to 12 months in jail. On indictment it carries a fine and up to three years.
A judge in the District Court, Judge Hughes, refused jurisdiction to try Mr Corcoran summarily on 2 December 2020. In the High Court, Phelan J. quashed that order. On 16 November 2023 the Court of Appeal reversed her decision, in a judgment by Edwards J. with Birmingham P. and Donnelly J. agreeing.
Mr Corcoran argued that a trial by jury in the Circuit Court would remove certain statutory entitlements, including probation without conviction under the Probation of Offenders Act 1907. He also argued that it exposes him to a higher sentence. He said reasons are required when a District Court judge refuses jurisdiction.
The DPP said the law is clear and no rights are lost. A judge must still choose a sentence within the summary level where appropriate, even after a jury finding of guilt.
Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J said the potential for a greater sentence is key to the application. Loss of statutory entitlements may not be as argued, but requires analysis. The court rejected the argument on reasons, because refusal for seriousness is the only reason a judge must give.
Leave is granted, subject to case management, on the application of Articles 38.1 and 38.2 of the Constitution to the classification and disposal of offences at summary level and on indictment.