The Supreme Court has granted Edel Doherty leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in her case against the Director of Public Prosecutions. The determination was delivered on 30 April 2024.
What is at stake for Ms Doherty is the level of penalty and the route of trial. On summary disposal, the offence carries a fine and up to 12 months in jail. On indictment, it carries a fine and up to three years. Ms Doherty argues that trial before a jury would remove certain statutory entitlements, including probation without conviction, and expose her to a higher sentence.
Two juveniles were convicted of murder in June 2019. Section 252 of the Children Act 2001 restricted identification of them. The allegation against Ms Doherty is that she identified the two on social media and added inflammatory comment.
On 28 October 2020 Judge O'Shea accepted jurisdiction in her case and nine others in the District Court. On 2 December 2020 Judge Hughes heard the alleged facts of each case and ruled on them collectively. He refused jurisdiction, because the offences were not minor.
Ms Doherty brought judicial review. Phelan J. quashed Judge Hughes's order in the High Court, finding a collective ruling did not meet the requirement that justice be seen to be done. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision on 16 November 2023.
The DPP said the law is clear and no rights are lost, because a judge must still choose a sentence within the summary level if appropriate.
Charleton J, Woulfe J and Collins J said the case raises a key issue about the classification and disposal of offences. They said the potential for a greater sentence is central, and a further appeal could clarify when a judge should refuse jurisdiction. They rejected the argument that reasons are required for refusing jurisdiction.
Leave was granted on the proper application of Articles 38.1 and 38.2 of the Constitution to offences at summary level and on indictment.