localnews.ie

Sharanjit Kaur and Janis Kass refused Supreme Court appeal over residence decision

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

The couple argued that neither of them was interviewed before the Minister for Justice found their marriage was one of convenience.

The Supreme Court has refused Sharanjit Kaur and Janis Kass leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision. The determination was delivered on 23 April 2024.

The case concerns the Minister for Justice's refusal to renew a residence card for Ms Kaur. The Minister found that the couple had entered a marriage of convenience, so that she could stay in the State. The decision was issued in November 2021.

The Minister relied heavily on a transcript of an interview Mr Kass gave to the GNIB. In it, he made admissions about the marriage. Mr Kass later swore an affidavit saying he had not made those statements. The Minister did not accept that account.

Ferriter J. refused to quash the decision in the High Court. The Court of Appeal upheld that on 12 December 2023. It found no conflict of fact between the couple, and treated the lack of a request for an interview as a factor with weight.

The couple argued that they were entitled to an oral stage in the process. Their points were the same as those in a related case, Z.K., decided in [2024] IESCDET 43.

O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Murray J. refused leave. They said the couple had not put forward a legal proposition that could govern their case. They also found no feature of the case that could have led to a different decision after an oral hearing.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal