The Supreme Court has refused Moide Hossan leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal decision in his case against the Minister for Justice and Equality. The determination was delivered on 23 April 2024, and his application was lodged out of time.
Mr Hossan challenged the Minister's finding that he had entered into a marriage of convenience to obtain residence rights. He held a residence card granted in October 2014 as the spouse of an EU citizen. After he was stopped by immigration officers on 19 February 2019, the Minister wrote to him in December 2019 raising concerns about the marriage and asking for further information. No documents about the relationship were provided.
The first-instance decision found the marriage was one of convenience. A review decision in April 2022 upheld that finding. The High Court, in a judgment by O'Regan J., refused to quash it, and the Court of Appeal upheld that refusal.
Mr Hossan argued that he was entitled to an oral hearing because his credibility was in issue. His arguments were identical to those in a related case, Z.K., decided in [2024] IESCDET 43.
O'Malley J., Hogan J. and Murray J. refused leave. They said he had not formulated a legal proposition that would govern his case, short of a right to an oral hearing in every such case. They also noted the absence of any evidence of a relationship between the spouses, and that he had not engaged with the Minister's concerns.