localnews.ie

Patrick Hyland evidence case: Garda Commissioner granted Supreme Court appeal

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The Court of Appeal had ruled that material found on the garda's phone under a search warrant could not be used directly in disciplinary proceedings.

The Supreme Court has granted the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána leave to appeal in the case of Garda Patrick Hyland. The determination was delivered on 19 April 2024.

The court said the issue reaches beyond this case. It will affect other disciplinary proceedings where the Commissioner has lawfully obtained material through a search. It also has implications for the use of lawfully obtained evidence before other regulatory bodies.

Garda Hyland is a serving member of the force and faced charges under the Garda Síochána (Discipline) Regulations 2007. Concerns were raised about a video clip he had sent to colleagues in a WhatsApp group. Two search warrants were obtained under the Child Trafficking and Pornography Act 1998, and his mobile phone was taken and examined.

The Director of Public Prosecutions directed that no charges should be brought. Disciplinary charges were brought on the video clip and on other material found on the phone.

Garda Hyland went to the High Court to stop that material being used in the disciplinary proceedings. Barr J. held that evidence from the criminal investigation could lawfully be used. The Court of Appeal reversed that. It held that, without appropriate legislation, material seized under a search warrant could not be used directly in a disciplinary investigation.

The Commissioner argued that the question is a matter of general public importance. Garda Hyland said it was a clear point of law on which the Court of Appeal's judgment is clear.

O'Malley J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. said the point is novel, with no previous authority in this jurisdiction. They said novelty alone is not enough, but the consequences go beyond the facts of the case.

The appeal will also consider whether the Commissioner or any investigative body has power under the Garda Síochána Act or otherwise to demand information from anyone for disciplinary proceedings.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal