The Supreme Court has refused Phillip Morrissey leave to appeal in his dispute with Allied Irish Banks plc, in a determination dated 19 January 2024. He had asked the court to hear an appeal against a Court of Appeal decision that refused him a stay.
AIB obtained judgment against Mr Morrissey in 2015 in the sum of approximately €25m. He signed a settlement in January 2020 covering the related proceedings. Mr Justice Barniville later held that AIB and Everyday were entitled to orders giving effect to it, and that Mr Morrissey could not withdraw his consent.
Mr Morrissey applied on 14 July 2023 for a stay on that order until his appeal was decided. Ms Justice Costello, sitting alone in the Court of Appeal, refused the stay. She held he had not advanced an arguable ground of appeal, because he accepted he had signed the consent orders.
He told the Supreme Court that the judge had ignored his claim of poor legal advice and had effectively pre-judged his appeal. The Supreme Court said it would have extended time, as his application was about two weeks late.
O'Donnell C.J., O'Malley J. and Hogan J. found Ms Justice Costello had applied well-established principles. They said no matter of general public importance or interest of justice arose, and the substantive appeal had by then been heard and judgment reserved.