localnews.ie

Damien Murphy refused Supreme Court appeal in claim against doctor over report

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

His claim followed an income protection claim that Canada Life refused; the Supreme Court said the interests of justice weigh heavily in favour of finality.

The Supreme Court has refused Damien Murphy leave to appeal in his claim against Robert Ryan, an occupational health physician. The determination was delivered on 8 April 2024.

The court said significant judicial time has already gone into Mr Murphy's complaints. It found that the interests of justice weigh heavily in favour of finality, and that there was no basis for a further appeal.

The case began after a road traffic accident in January 2010. Mr Murphy claimed on an income protection policy with Canada Life Assurance (Ireland) Limited. Dr Ryan carried out an independent medical examination and sent a report to the insurer, which refused to pay.

Mr Murphy complained to the Financial Services Ombudsman, who found it was reasonable for Canada Life to conclude he no longer met the policy criteria. His High Court claim against Canada Life was struck out on 30 July 2015, and the Court of Appeal upheld that. The Supreme Court refused leave in 2016.

He issued the present proceedings against Dr Ryan on 21 July 2017, seeking damages for matters including negligence and defamation. Noonan J. dismissed them, finding no claim could be advanced on a stateable basis. The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal.

Baker J., Woulfe J. and Collins J. considered his out-of-time application and found no matter of general public importance. The court also noted its disquiet at the scandalous nature of some of the matters pleaded.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal