localnews.ie

Jonathan O'Flaherty oral fluid drug test case: DPP granted Supreme Court appeal

By Saoirse Doyle

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will decide whether gardaí can require a driver to wait for the result of a roadside oral fluid test, after the High Court said they cannot.

The Director of Public Prosecutions has been granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. The case is against Jonathan O'Flaherty and is brought at the suit of Garda Colin McCluskey. The determination is dated 25 March 2024.

The appeal comes from a consultative case stated by Judge Malone of the District Court. That is a request for the High Court's opinion on a point of law.

The question concerns section 10(4) of the Road Traffic Act 2010. That section lets a garda require a driver to give a sample of oral fluid for drug testing. The judge asked whether it also lets a garda require the driver to remain until the result is known.

Mr O'Flaherty was told he had to wait for up to one hour. The test results were available within a shorter period.

Mr Justice Simons delivered the High Court judgment on 15 November 2023. He held that the legislation gives gardaí no such power, either expressly or by implication.

The DPP asked to appeal directly to the Supreme Court. It said the decision may significantly affect other Garda powers on intoxicated driving and road traffic enforcement. It said a number of other cases have been adjourned pending an appeal. It said a further appeal from the Court of Appeal would be inevitable if leave was refused now. It also asked for a priority hearing.

Mr O'Flaherty agreed that the matter raises issues of general public importance. He did not oppose the application.

O'Malley J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. accepted that the application meets the constitutional criteria. They granted leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The court said a hearing date can be set early if case management time limits are kept. It said no formal order for priority is needed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal