The Supreme Court has refused Philip McCarthy leave to appeal against the Court of Appeal's decision upholding his conviction by a summary court-martial. The determination was delivered on 15 March 2024, in a case brought by the Director of Military Prosecutions.
Mr McCarthy was convicted of false imprisonment and assault, and of conduct to the prejudice of good order and discipline. He was acquitted on several related charges. The charges arose from an incident involving a fellow Defence Forces recruit at Sarsfield Barracks in Limerick on 18 July 2021.
The Military Judge accepted the evidence of the fellow recruit and the prosecution witnesses, who had seen his injuries. Mr McCarthy denied any violence. He was sentenced to one week's detention and discharged from the Defence Forces.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal on 31 October 2023. It said the appeal was an attempt to go behind the Military Judge's findings of fact.
Mr McCarthy argued that appeals from a summary court-martial need a more exacting standard of review. Baker J., Woulfe J. and Collins J. said no such issue arose in the Court of Appeal's judgment. They found no point of law of general public importance, and said it was not in the interests of justice to allow a further appeal because he had been legally represented and had already appealed.