localnews.ie

Olumide Smith refused Supreme Court appeal in Cisco race discrimination case

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal concerned the Court of Appeal's refusal to remove two judges from his case after he complained about them to the Judicial Conduct Committee.

The Supreme Court has refused Olumide Smith leave to appeal against a Court of Appeal ruling in his employment case against Cisco Systems Internetworking (Ireland) Limited, in a determination dated 8 March 2024.

Mr Smith, who represents himself, was dismissed by Cisco in or about July 2013. He claimed discrimination on grounds of race over promotion, pay and dismissal. An Adjudication Officer found no discrimination in relation to pay and held other complaints out of time. The Labour Court then affirmed that decision.

Mr Smith appealed on a point of law to the High Court, where Meenan J. dismissed the appeal. He then appealed to the Court of Appeal and objected to Binchy J. and Allen J. sitting on his case. He said they had decided earlier matters involving him and that he had complained about them to the Judicial Conduct Committee.

On 21 July 2023 the Court of Appeal refused to remove either judge. Whelan J. said a fair-minded observer would see no reasonable basis to doubt their impartiality.

Mr Smith applied to the Supreme Court on 23 November 2023. Dunne J., Baker J. and Woulfe J. refused leave. They said the decision applied well-established principles on recusal, and that a complaint to the Judicial Conduct Committee cannot automatically disqualify a judge.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal