localnews.ie

Alan Lynskey refused Supreme Court appeal over Swinford public roads decision

By Eimear Byrne

Historic decision · Decision date:

Mr Lynskey had already won an order quashing Mayo County Council's declaration that roads in the Rath Dubh estate were public, but appealed over the grounds and costs.

The Supreme Court has refused Alan Lynskey leave to appeal in his case against Mayo County Council. The determination was delivered on 23 February 2024.

On 1 September 2021 the council declared roads in Phase 1 of the Rath Dubh housing estate in Swinford, Co. Mayo to be public roads. Mr Lynskey owns the folio containing the roads. He told the council he had not dedicated them for public use. He then brought judicial review proceedings to quash the decision.

The council did not oppose the case. On 19 May 2022 it conceded that it could not show it had considered whether the roads were of general public utility, or his submission. Bolger J. granted the order quashing the declaration on 17 October 2022. She allowed him to offset his costs up to 19 May 2022 against the council's costs after that date.

The Court of Appeal rejected both of Mr Lynskey's grounds of appeal, on the other pleaded grounds and on costs. He asked the Supreme Court to hear a further appeal, claiming that the courts had wrongly recorded that he consented to the order.

Baker J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. refused leave. They said the matters were particular to the facts, no issue of law had been identified and he had been entirely successful. The court noted his application was incomplete and that he did not respond to requests to complete it.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal