localnews.ie

Patrick Kelly granted Supreme Court appeal on judge bias in UCD discrimination case

By Niamh Kearney

Historic decision · Decision date:

The court will hear one question only: whether a judge's close relative working at a party's solicitors meets the test for objective bias.

The Supreme Court has granted Patrick Kelly leave to appeal on one issue arising from his long-running dispute with University College Dublin. The determination was delivered on 22 February 2024, and the appeal will go directly from the High Court.

The issue is whether the fact that a close relative of a judge is employed as a solicitor in the firm representing a party meets the well-established test for objective bias. The court said this is a matter of general public importance, not covered by case law to date, and that exceptional circumstances justify a direct appeal.

The court has asked the parties to address the law on objective bias, including the judicial conduct guidelines, whether the relative's status or the size of the firm matters, and an earlier case, Kenny v Trinity College Dublin. It also considers that the Law Society of Ireland's views may help.

Mr Kelly, who has no lawyer, was invited to contact the Registrar within seven days if he wants a solicitor and counsel assigned to him under a voluntary scheme.

The dispute dates to March 2002, when UCD decided not to offer Mr Kelly a place on a social science course. He made a gender discrimination complaint to the Equality Tribunal, which found he had not established a prima facie case. His later request for redacted copies of documents was refused by the Circuit Court and then by the High Court.

Mr Kelly alleged bias by the High Court judge, including connections with UCD. The court found that none of those connections, individually or together, could meet the test for objective bias. It also refused leave on his other grounds, including his EU law and fair hearing claims.

UCD opposed the application. It described the appeal as an abuse of process in a request for the same documents that Mr Kelly has pursued for about 17 years.

O'Donnell C.J., Woulfe J. and Donnelly J. granted leave on the relative-in-the-firm issue only.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal