The Supreme Court has refused Dana Rosemary Scallon leave to appeal directly from the High Court. The determination was delivered on 12 February 2024.
The case began with two identical defamation claims by Susan Gorrell and Susan Stein against Ms Scallon and TV3 Television Network Limited. TV3 settled with the plaintiffs on 30 June 2014 and apologised in court. Ms Scallon did not settle.
The proceedings against her were struck out on 21 July 2021, after security for costs of €150,000 was ordered and not provided. She then sought a contribution or indemnity from TV3 for her costs.
On 13 July 2023, Mr Justice O'Moore refused that relief. He said the claim against TV3 was struck out in 2014, so it was no longer a co-defendant. He added that she had delayed too long to join it as a third party.
Ms Scallon asked the Supreme Court to hear a leapfrog appeal on when a notice of contribution or indemnity must be issued.
O'Malley J., Baker J. and Hogan J. refused leave. The court said "no exceptional circumstances arise in the present application". It said the case was decided on procedural grounds, and the issues can be dealt with in the Court of Appeal, where an appeal against the same order has been filed.