Gerard Harrington, a farmer, has been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court over his conviction for making a false report about missing cattle. O'Malley J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. delivered the determination on 18 December 2024.
Mr Harrington was convicted in the Circuit Court of making a false report or statement tending to give rise to apprehension for the safety of property, under section 12 of the Criminal Law Act 1976. The report was that a number of his cattle had gone missing from his farm. The prosecution case was that they had been moved to a shed on a neighbouring farm and that he knew where they were.
The court heard that gardaí invited him to the station, told him he was not under arrest and cautioned him. He took part in a voluntary interview, which was written down. At trial he argued he should have been arrested so that he could have legal advice.
The Court of Appeal dismissed his appeal against conviction on 16 May 2024. It found the trial satisfactory and the verdict safe.
In his application to the Supreme Court he raised an EU directive on the right to information in criminal proceedings, which was not relied on at trial. The Supreme Court said the point was entirely hypothetical in his case, because he made no admissions. It said no matter met the constitutional criteria for leave.