localnews.ie

Muhammed Imran granted Supreme Court appeal against Minister for Justice over revoked residence card

By Rory Hanlon

Historic decision · Decision date:

The appeal will test whether a proportionality assessment is required under EU law before a permanent residence card is revoked for false documents.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal by Muhammed Imran against the Minister for Justice over the revocation of his permanent residence card. It granted him leave on 18 December 2024. O'Malley J., Murray J. and Donnelly J. made the determination.

Mr Imran married an EU citizen on 10 January 2011. A derived right of residence was granted on 6 July 2011, and permanent residence was granted on 14 July 2016. The application relied on invoices from his wife's childminding business.

On 14 May 2018 the Minister told him she believed the documents were false and misleading. She revoked his permission to reside on 19 November 2018. On review, a decision of 13 December 2021 upheld the revocation. By then the Minister accepted that the marriage was not one of convenience, but she still found the invoices false and misleading.

On 22 June 2023, the High Court (Barr J.) quashed that decision. It held that the Minister had to carry out a proportionality assessment. The Court of Appeal reversed that on 19 April 2024. It held that no standalone proportionality assessment is required where fraud is found, and noted that Mr Imran had not challenged the finding about the documents.

Mr Imran then applied to the Supreme Court, and the Minister opposed leave. The Supreme Court said the constitutional criteria were met. It granted leave on whether Article 35 of the Citizens Directive, as transposed by Article 27 of the 2015 Regulations, requires a proportionate measure. The parties must also address whether a reference to the Court of Justice of the European Union is needed.

Sources

Source: Courts Service of Ireland. Read the linked determination for the court’s exact decision.

Request a correction or removal